Ah hot buttered cuttlefish, our favourite Chinese dish that isn't really Chinese at all. Last year we had Barracuda taking our top spot but the HBC scene has actually gotten a lot more competitive and varied in terms of preparations. In light of that, this year we're extending the list to a top 10.
One thing you'll probably notice is the fact that many of the classic Sri Lankan Chinese restaurants like Chinese Dragon & Flower Drum haven't made the cut. While most of them are still quite decent and offer some very reasonable prices, they just don't match when it comes to the most important factor- the taste.
This year we're taking a slightly different approach by broadening our spectrum, so you'll see a mix of different cuisines, cafes and even clubs making up our top 10.
This top 10 is based on our experiences so it is subjective. There's a good chance that there may be some great HBCs that we haven't tried yet, so let us know your favourites in the comments section.
Starting things off is the HBC at 168, which is incidentally the only veteran on this list. Two things we appreciated about this was that while the batter was crispy, it wasn't dripping with oil and the pieces were just the right size. A portion for three at Rs. 600 is also a pretty tough price to beat. If you're trying to pick between the old school restaurants based on HBC this is what we'd go for.
CSC is the odd one out on this list since it's the only club. This is one of the two wet HBCs (those with a bit of a sauce) on this list (see #3 for the other). In fact it was CSC that came up with the dish initially, it just so happens happens that the imitators ended up doing a better job of it.
So we're cheating a bit with this entry but we think that ZaZa's batter fried calamari (Rs. 300) deserved to be on this list. It's technically not an HBC but we felt it would be unfair for it to not be included on a list of fried cuttlefish dishes. What you get is crispy, well seasoned calamari rings served with one of the best chilli mayo dips that we've had in a while. We generally drop in during their happy hour deal and get two of these for the price of one.
Waves is a new beachside restaurant in Dehiwala that's become popular for hosting parties. Their HBC at Rs. 680 is perhaps on of the most generous portions we have come across. Taste-wise it comes off pleasantly sweet, drawing a chewy texture from the thickness of the batter. It isn’t outstanding but it is a great deal for Rs.680. There is barely any vegetable and chilli “garnish” which most other restaurants use to fill up the plate.
The best thing about the HBC at the Boat Haus Cafe is the fact that it's super fresh since they give you the day's catch, and the fact that you can decide how much you get (Rs. 270 for 100g). They prepare it with a batter that's thicker than most others but it isn't dense or hard. The real hero, however, is that fresh cuttlefish which works brilliantly with a heat of the added dried chillies.
Beach Wadiya has been Bamba's most popular beachside restaurant for a while now. They recently had a bit of a fire but they were back on their feet in no time. What's unique about Wadiya's HBC is that they fry the cuttlefish in a
thin bread crumb batter which was a great change up from the
contemporaries. The seasoning was also on point with a good balance of
saltiness and spice. The portion for Rs. 575 wasn't huge but still plenty for two.
Barrucuda was our top dog last year but they find themselves relegated a few spots this time around. Truth is that there's very little separating our top 4. Their HBC is still excellent with a light, flavoursome and crunchy batter on top of perfectly cooked cuttlefish . This one is very much in line with the classic HBC preparation, so purists will likely pick this over some of our top 3.
There's a good chance that you not have heard of Bixton Street Cafe. Partly due to the fact that they're very new and also because it's a small street cafe in Mt. Lavinia. All of their offerings aren't great but their HBC is definitely a standout dish. This one is both wet and crispy at the same time, essentially Colombo Swimming Club's preparation done better. It's got all the flavour of a classic HBC along with a creamy butter sauce which just makes it that much better.
The Station has become one of my favourite spots to hang back and grab a beer. One thing that took us by surprise during our last review was how surprisingly good their Sri Lankan Chinese was. Theirs is the culmination of everything that locals expect in a good HBC - crispy batter, well cooked cuttlefish, adequate spice and heat with a large portion at an affordable price.
The Boulevard was recently revamped into one of the best Thai restaurants in Colombo. This may be a controversial pick but we loved their Thai HBC. At Rs. 1350 it's the most expensive on this list by quite a bit, but chef Mama has really nailed it in terms of flavour and texture. This one is entirely different from the Chinese renditions since they add a lot more ingredients, a more puffy batter and an almost glaze like sauce. You get to taste a bit of everything from salty to sweet to tangy, which makes this one our top pick for 2015.
If you ever feel like some retail therapy, here's a list of sites that deliver all the way here.
Countries that let you in without a fuss with your Lankan passport
Very tasty Sri Lankan Chinese & Indian Food. But some are spoiled!
A home-based venture that makes superb Maqlooba from a recipe older than three decades.
Alerics Ice Choc is back!